Parenting, Childhood, and American Values in 1940: Gladys Taber’s “Parents Can’t Help It”
When Americans picked up the January 27, 1940 issue of The Saturday Evening Post, they weren’t just reaching for entertainment. They were turning the pages of one of the nation’s most influential cultural barometers. This particular issue carried a memorable short story titled “Parents Can’t Help It” by Gladys Taber, a writer beloved for her gentle but perceptive explorations of home, family, and community life.
For readers in 1940, Taber’s tale was more than a fictional diversion. It was a reflection of American households during a decade shaped by the Great Depression and shadowed by the looming clouds of global war. Families recognized themselves in the characters — a mother named Andrea, a father named Phil, and their strong-willed young son Billy — whose quarrels, frustrations, and small reconciliations captured the universal truth of parenting: raising children has always been as exasperating as it is rewarding.
At a time when the world was anxious about the rise of dictators abroad and the uncertainty of America’s role in global affairs, stories like this reminded readers of what truly mattered at home: the resilience of ordinary families navigating everyday struggles.
The winter of 1940 was a period of transition. The Great Depression, which had gripped the nation throughout the 1930s, had finally begun to ease, but its lessons of thrift, resourcefulness, and resilience lingered. Millions of American families had lived through unemployment, rationing, and sacrifice, and those values carried over into how they raised their children.
Meanwhile, the Second World War had already erupted in Europe. Nazi Germany had invaded Poland in September 1939, and Britain and France were fully engaged in the conflict. The United States was still officially neutral, but the debate over involvement raged. Against this turbulent backdrop, family-centered stories in The Saturday Evening Post carried particular weight. They reminded readers that even while the world trembled, the core of American life — the family unit — remained a source of strength and continuity.
Gladys Taber’s “Parents Can’t Help It” spoke directly to this cultural moment. It captured how parents, shaped by hardship, sought to instill discipline, independence, and obedience in their children — even when the children pushed back with stubborn resistance. Andrea and Phil embodied the Depression-era parents who believed in rules, thrift, and responsibility, while young Billy represented the new generation, full of energy, resistance, and defiance. Their clashes dramatized the tension between parental expectations and childhood rebellion, a theme just as relevant in 1940 as it is today.
This was not just a story about one family. It was a snapshot of American parenthood at a turning point in history — showing how values of the past were being tested by the energy of a younger generation poised to grow up in wartime America.
By 1940, The Saturday Evening Post was more than a magazine — it was an institution. With circulation in the millions, it was delivered to homes across the country every week, serving as a shared cultural experience for families in every state. Unlike newspapers, which emphasized breaking news, the Post offered a mixture of fiction, essays, humor, art, and commentary, making it a magazine that could be read by every member of the household.
The January 27, 1940 issue exemplified this blend. Gladys Taber’s story was accompanied by charming illustrations by Nicholas Riley, whose drawings made the struggles of Andrea, Phil, and Billy come alive visually. One image showed Billy sulking with his suitcase packed for camp, his reluctance practically leaping off the page. Another depicted Andrea’s exasperation with her son’s endless protests. These illustrations weren’t just decoration — they were a way of turning fiction into something that felt real, familiar, and deeply relatable.
For families gathered around the fireplace or the kitchen table, the Post became a bridge. Just as Life Magazine used photographs to bring the war into American homes, the Post used illustrated fiction to bring domestic humor and pathos into those same spaces. Parents who had just spent a long week working or running a household could open this issue and see their own struggles reflected — but softened through wit and storytelling.
The effect was powerful: The Saturday Evening Post helped shape how Americans thought about themselves. It reinforced the idea that while international crises mattered, so too did the small, everyday battles of family life.
The cover of the January 27, 1940 issue reflected the Post’s enduring focus on Americana — the idealized images of ordinary people that had made it famous. Unlike the stark war photography appearing in Life, the Post favored the reassuring art of illustrators like Norman Rockwell (though not every issue featured his work). These covers celebrated humor, innocence, and domesticity at a time when headlines were full of dread.
Inside, Gladys Taber’s story carried the same spirit. Andrea and Phil were not depicted as flawless parents, but as ordinary adults trying — sometimes failing — to navigate the impossible task of raising a strong-willed child. Billy, meanwhile, was no villain, but a portrait of youthful stubbornness and independence. Taber’s narrative voice captured both the humor and the frustration of these moments, which made readers laugh in recognition.
This balance of realism and entertainment was exactly what made The Saturday Evening Post the cultural giant of its era. It spoke to readers not with lectures, but with relatable, lived-in details — the very kind of details that made “Parents Can’t Help It” stand out as both funny and true.
Like Life Magazine’s wartime photo-essays, Taber’s short story was full of vivid moments that readers carried with them long after finishing the issue. Among the most memorable:
-
The Reluctant Camper – Billy’s resistance to going off to Camp Happy Horizons was a storyline many parents understood firsthand. His excuses, fears, and bargaining reflected the timeless battle between children wanting to stay home and parents urging independence.
-
Food Battles at the Table – Billy’s refusal to eat certain foods — and Andrea’s weary persistence — mirrored one of the most universal struggles of family life, one that parents then and now know too well.
-
The Clash of Generations – Andrea and Phil represented parents hardened by the Depression’s lessons of thrift and endurance, while Billy embodied the youthful push for freedom and resistance to rules.
-
Humor in Parenting – Despite the frustration, Taber’s tone emphasized laughter. Parents could read the story and chuckle, recognizing their own arguments replayed in Andrea and Phil’s household.
-
The Strength of Family Bonds – Beneath the quarrels, Taber reminded readers that parenting is ultimately an act of love. The exasperation and the laughter were two sides of the same coin.
Each of these moments resonated deeply in 1940, and they still do today. Parents then — like parents now — could see themselves in the story’s small triumphs and defeats.
The January 27, 1940 issue of The Saturday Evening Post holds strong value for collectors today, not only for its charming fiction but for its cultural importance.
Why is it collectible?
-
Historical Timing – Published on the eve of America’s entry into World War II, it reflects the calm before the storm in American culture, when family concerns dominated before wartime sacrifices reshaped domestic life.
-
Gladys Taber’s Legacy – As a writer, Taber went on to become one of America’s most beloved chroniclers of domestic and rural life, especially through her later Stillmeadow books. This story captures her voice at an earlier stage in her career.
-
Illustrations – Nicholas Riley’s drawings are an artifact in themselves, a visual record of 1940s illustration style and the ways artists captured family dynamics.
-
Cultural Snapshot – Beyond the short story, the issue includes advertisements, commentary, and art that provide a full picture of American life in early 1940.
-
Collector Demand – Issues of The Saturday Evening Post from the 1940s are highly sought after, especially those with strong cover art or memorable fiction.
For modern collectors, holding this issue is not just about reading a story. It is about owning an artifact of American cultural history, one that reflects the humor, struggle, and love of family life on the eve of global war.
Stories like “Parents Can’t Help It” remain timeless because they capture what is most human: the push-and-pull between generations. Just as Life Magazine’s photojournalism preserved the realities of war, the Post’s family fiction preserved the domestic truths of American life.
Today, when parenting advice is often consumed in fleeting online posts, these vintage stories remind us that the dilemmas have not changed. Children resist chores, parents struggle with patience, families laugh in exasperation. These stories endure because they are honest, humorous, and deeply human.
This is why vintage Post issues matter. They are not simply magazines. They are time capsules of American identity, carrying within them the voices, art, and values of the past.
If you’re ready to explore more, the January 27, 1940 issue is just one jewel among thousands. From the 1920s through the 1960s, The Saturday Evening Post chronicled the evolving story of America — from Norman Rockwell’s iconic covers to the fiction, essays, and advertisements that captured everyday life.
👉 Browse the full collection of original Saturday Evening Post magazines here:
https://originalmagazines.com/collections/saturday-evening-post-1
Whether you are a collector, a cultural historian, or someone honoring family history, these magazines offer something extraordinary: a way to see America as it first saw itself.
The January 27, 1940 issue of The Saturday Evening Post remains one of the most fascinating and heartwarming glimpses into prewar American domestic life. Gladys Taber’s “Parents Can’t Help It” gave voice to the exasperation and love of parenthood, showing that even in a world shadowed by looming war, the struggles of the family kitchen table remained central.
To hold this issue today is to hold a slice of American life preserved in ink and paper — a record of how families lived, laughed, and endured in 1940. For collectors and readers alike, it is more than a magazine. It is a living artifact of cultural history that continues to resonate across generations.