Border Without Bayonets: Peace and Trust on the U.S.-Canada Frontier
When Americans picked up the January 6, 1940 issue of The Saturday Evening Post, they held more than just another weekly magazine. They were encountering a vision of international relations unlike any other in the world. This particular issue carried a feature article titled “Border Without Bayonets” by Jack Alexander — a striking narrative about the world’s longest undefended boundary between the United States and Canada.
For readers in the United States, this was more than a story of geography. It was a reminder that in an age when barbed wire and marching armies scarred the world, there still existed a frontier defined not by force but by mutual trust, shared communities, and peaceful coexistence.
The winter of 1940 was marked by global uncertainty. Only months earlier, in September 1939, Nazi Germany had invaded Poland, igniting the Second World War. Britain and France were already fighting on the Western Front, while the Soviet Union was expanding its own influence in Eastern Europe. Across the Atlantic, Americans debated how deeply their nation should become involved.
At home, the United States was still recovering from the Great Depression, which had shaped the 1930s. While the country prepared for the possibility of war, many citizens longed for stability and peace. Against this backdrop, the story of a 3,985-mile border without armies felt both reassuring and profound.
The Post’s feature highlighted the special relationship between the United States and Canada, two nations that had once fought but now lived as neighbors without fear. In a world where violence and occupation were daily headlines, this article showed Americans that trust between nations was possible.
By 1940, The Saturday Evening Post was one of the most widely read magazines in America. Known for blending fiction, humor, essays, art, and cultural commentary, it reached into millions of households. Its covers, often painted by Norman Rockwell, became some of the most iconic depictions of American life.
The interior cover of this article of the January 6, 1940 issue was different. Instead of a Rockwell illustration, it featured a photograph of the Canadian Customs station at Emerson, Manitoba. A horse-drawn sleigh approached the checkpoint in a snow-covered landscape. The scene was quiet, ordinary — yet symbolically powerful.
Unlike the militarized images coming out of Europe, this cover projected a message of peaceful borders and cooperative neighbors. Inside, Jack Alexander’s reporting described how border towns like Pembina, North Dakota, and Emerson, Manitoba shared schools, newspapers, and even hospital services. Farmers crossed freely for trade, and families traveled back and forth for shopping or community events.
The Post’s blend of local storytelling and national reflection captured its enduring power. It was more than a magazine; it was a cultural mirror, showing Americans who they were and what they valued. In 1940, it offered a comforting reminder that ordinary people could live without bayonets between them.
The interior cover photograph itself set the tone: plain, authentic, and deeply human. No generals, no parades, no speeches — just a sleigh in the snow and a customs station. It symbolized how everyday life on the border was lived not in suspicion, but in trust and familiarity.
Inside, Alexander’s article demonstrated what made The Saturday Evening Post so influential. It wasn’t just about facts — it was about atmosphere, community, and cultural connection. Readers learned of Manitoba’s melting pot towns, where immigrants from Ukraine, Sweden, and England built farms alongside long-established settlers. They read about how local hockey teams, churches, and newspapers often crossed the border as freely as their citizens did.
Other publications might have focused only on war dispatches or economic news. The Post gave its readers something else: a vivid example of international friendship at a time when such stories were rare. This mix of narrative journalism and cultural reflection is why the magazine remained a staple of American life for generations.
The Open Frontier – Alexander emphasized that the U.S.-Canadian border was maintained by customs clerks, not soldiers. Hunters, traders, and families moved across with ease, a sharp contrast to Europe’s militarized boundaries.
Manitoba’s Melting Pot – In towns like Rosena, Manitoba, immigrants from Ukraine, Sweden, and other nations built thriving communities. Diversity, rather than division, defined life at the border.
Shared Communities – From International Falls, Minnesota, to Fort Frances, Ontario, towns relied on each other for medical care, commerce, and recreation. Winter carnivals and local sports often brought citizens from both sides together.
Trust in Place of Troops – The absence of bayonets symbolized a deeper faith in democratic institutions. Unlike the heavily policed frontiers in Europe, the U.S. and Canada demonstrated that peace could be maintained by law and custom rather than force.
The International Peace Garden – Dedicated in 1932, the monument on the Manitoba–North Dakota border bore an inscription: “To God in His Glory. We two nations dedicate this garden, and pledge ourselves that as long as men shall live, we will not take up arms against one another.” The article highlighted this as the ultimate symbol of friendship.
Together, these stories created a larger narrative: the U.S. and Canada shared more than a border — they shared trust, culture, and ideals.
For collectors, the January 6, 1940 issue of The Saturday Evening Post is more than old paper. It is an artifact from a moment when peace was the exception, not the rule.
Why is it collectible?
-
Historical Timing – Published as World War II began, this issue offered a hopeful counterpoint, showing readers that not every international relationship was defined by conflict.
-
Unique Cover Photography – While Norman Rockwell covers dominate the Post’s legacy, this photographic interior cover is a prized snapshot of real life at the border in 1940.
-
Cultural Significance – The story reflects values of trust, cooperation, and unity, themes that remain relevant today.
-
Collector Demand – Saturday Evening Post issues from the 1940s are highly sought after, particularly those tied to major historical events or themes. This one appeals not only to Americana collectors but also to historians of diplomacy and international relations.
Holding this magazine is like holding a time capsule of goodwill, proof that peaceful frontiers could exist in a world otherwise bracing for war.
The Saturday Evening Post endures because it was never just a magazine — it was a reflection of American values. Its pages combined art, literature, commentary, and reporting in a way that no single publication has since matched.
Articles like “Border Without Bayonets” endure because they are more than stories. They are time capsules of optimism. In an age where most borders meant tension, this issue captured a rare and lasting vision of peace.
For collectors, Post magazines are not simply keepsakes. They are physical witnesses to the 20th century, reminders of how Americans understood themselves and their neighbors.
If you’re looking to explore this issue or others like it, authentic Saturday Evening Post magazines from the 1930s through the 1970s are available in our collection. Together, they trace entire decades of American history, culture, and art as it unfolded in real time.
👉 Browse the full collection here: Original Saturday Evening Post Magazines
Whether you’re a seasoned collector, a history buff, or someone preserving family memories, these magazines offer something unique: a chance to hold history in your hands.
The January 6, 1940 issue of The Saturday Evening Post remains one of the most meaningful publications of its era. Through Jack Alexander’s “Border Without Bayonets,” it reminded Americans that peaceful borders were possible, even in a world hurtling toward war.
Its interior cover, its reporting, and its message endure as symbols of trust and cooperation. For collectors, it is not just a magazine — it is an artifact of hope, preserving a vision of what international friendship can achieve.
Holding this issue is holding a moment when two nations pledged not to take up arms against one another — and kept that promise.